| Platinum | Sandy's Donuts & Coffee Shop |
| Gold | GiGi's Cupcakes |
| Silver | Jen's Bakery |
| Silver | Nichole's Fine Pastry |
| Bronze | Becky's Gluten Free |
| Bronze | Nosh Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Bella's Dulce Sweets & Treats |
| Top Pick | Cookie Krums |
| Top Pick | Kreps Family Farm |
| Top Pick | Nothing Bundt Cakes |