| Platinum | Beer & Fish Company |
| Gold | Oasis Cafe |
| Silver | Deep Blue Seafood |
| Bronze | Mangata Wine & Raw Bar |
| Top Pick | Cork'n Cleaver |
| Top Pick | Doolittles |
| Top Pick | Fryn' Pan Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mezzaluna |
| Top Pick | Red Lobster |
| Top Pick | Wild Willie's Seafood Steams Pots to-Go |