| Platinum | Sandy's Donuts & Coffee Shop |
| Gold | Becky's Gluten Free |
| Silver | Fardough Donuts |
| Bronze | Beans Coffee Bar |
| Bronze | GiGi's Cupcakes |
| Top Pick | Breadsmith |
| Top Pick | Duck Duck Goose Food Company |
| Top Pick | Hornbacher's |
| Top Pick | Pan-O-Gold Baking Company |
| Top Pick | Red River Coffee Co. |