| Platinum | Randy's University Diner |
| Gold | Randy's Diner Too |
| Silver | Kroll's Diner |
| Bronze | Wurst Bier Hall |
| Top Pick | Cracked Pepper |
| Top Pick | Deaner's Diner |
| Top Pick | Pot Belly |
| Top Pick | Rising Bread Co. |
| Top Pick | Rustica Eatery and Tavern |
| Top Pick | Smiling Moose / BurgerSear |