| Platinum | Mystical Methods Metaphysical & Oddities Shoppe |
| Gold | First Avenue Market |
| Silver | Sweet Dreams Confections |
| Bronze | Unglued |
| Top Pick | Handpicked Goods |
| Top Pick | Heritage Hjemkomst Interpretive |
| Top Pick | Lunatique Boutique |
| Top Pick | Minn-Dak Market |
| Top Pick | Mystic Moth Studio |
| Top Pick | Vintage Point LLP |