| Platinum | Indulge Bakery |
| Platinum | Nichole's Fine Pastry |
| Platinum | Silver Lining Creamery |
| Gold | Becky's Gluten Free |
| Silver | GiGi's Cupcakes |
| Bronze | Randy's Diner Too |
| Top Pick | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Top Pick | Lundys |
| Top Pick | Moonrise Cafe |
| Top Pick | Randy's University Diner |